Ptolemy IV-V - Tyre Series II
These denomination series also have limited coin size ranges. There are actually three different series with different controls. We have only the 'hemidrachm' and smaller sizes, with two main leg monogram types for this unusual 'decorated' series. Tyre issues of these unusual 'decorated' reverse designs have PI, PI-T, PI-T-O, and AP (ALPHA RHO) monograms. This is an enigmatic series for which the basis of the highly decorated reverses is not known, though the combination of filetted cornucopiaea on the eagle's shoulders with a club (of Tyre) or other mintmark is seen on some coins of Ptolemy II. The PI control letter, exergal letters, and unusual decorations (caps of the dioscuri, stars, etc.) are echoed in some silver and gold issues that tie these most likely to Ptolemy V. A precise attribution for the others remains a topic of scholarly investigation. Those with PI-T and PI-T-O are attributed by some to Ptolemais but the use of mint designations in the usual position of control letters as well as the clear presence of the (presumably) Tyre club mark is good reason to question that, as is the existence of related precious metal coins bearing related control marks that are likely attributable to other Phoenician mints. We show these series together here because they unusual 'decorations' on the reverse and Tyre club seem to make them related to one another but the reignal attribution may indeed span Ptolemy IV and V. The production quality of some AP types (such as the hemidrachm shown here) is high enough, with carefully made very round flan with clean rounded edges as well as high artistic quality of its reverse, to suggest even production under Ptolemy III. Two coins shown here merit additional attention. The coin with caduceus countermark is apparently unique and the caduceus as a countermark is not on any other Ptolemaic coins we have seen nor mentioned in Noeske's paper on countermarks of Ptolemaic coins. The city location or other meaning of the caduceus countermark is unknown but that symbol is associated with certain Greek cities such as Tarsos, as is the club seen on some Tarsos coins. It is possible these are Asia Minor issues yet to be better understood. Parts of Cilicia were under Ptolemaic control for much of the 3rd C. BC and only taken by Antiochos III near its end. The coin with PI-T-O control with a size in between Svoronos 1058 and 1060, a 'half size' of Sv 1058, appears to be a unique specimen as well. The AP control types are the most frequently seen, sometimes nicely made (as the example shown here) and other times somewhat crude and of poor metal. The other types are all moderately to extremely scarce. The larger coins of these types sometimes show striations under the Zeus figure which appear to be part of the die itself, possibly indicating a re-working of an earlier die after removing its original somewhat design. These are altogether enigmatic, scarce, and among the more interesting Ptolemaic bronzes of the 3rd C. BC. It is possible these represent the last Ptolemaic bronze coinage of Tyre before it fell to Antiochos III during the reign of Ptolemy V, or perhaps some of them are from an Asia Minor location that fell to Seleukid control a bit earlier.
|


36mm - 36gm
Sv1251 - AP
|


18mm - 4gm
Sv1252 - AP
|


16mm - 2gm
Sv1253 - AP
|


36mm - 36gm
Sv1058 - PI-T-O
|


36mm - 36gm
Sv1058 - PI-T-O
This specimen (unique) with caduceus countermark at right.
|


28mm - 18gm
Svxxxx - PI-T-O
Uncatalogued type similar to 1/2 denomination of Sv1058.
|


20mm - 6gm
Sv1060 - PI-T
|


36mm - 36gm
Sv1059 - PI
Unusual EP in exergue.
|


28mm - 18gm
Sv1320 - PI
Unusual IE in exergue.
|